2024 Reading Recap: The Best and Worst Books I’ve Read
We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.
The clock strikes December, and here we are—another year of reading adventures behind us. My 2024 reading recap is a rollercoaster of plot twists, broken spines (the books, not mine), and some questionable author decisions. From August heartbreakers to October masterpieces, and let’s not forget the November duds that had me questioning my life choices, this list is more than just a review. It’s a story of highs and lows, the books that consumed my time, and the ones I wish I could unread. Let’s dive into my 2024 reading journey—month by month, book by book, and author by author.
Let’s Dive into the 2024 Reading Recap
January
Best: The Shadow of the Gods by John Gwynne (3.5 stars)
When I picked up The Shadow of the Gods, I wasn’t sure what to expect. With all the hype around John Gwynne and The Bloodsworn Trilogy, it felt like an experiment—stepping outside my usual romantasy comfort zone into epic fantasy. Right away, I was captivated by Gwynne’s older, more intricate writing style, reminiscent of Robert Jordan, Michael J. Sullivan, and Robin Hobb. Though this style added richness, it also came with challenging jargon and unfamiliar terms. A pronunciation guide helped, but having it earlier would have eased the learning curve.
Gwynne’s prose shines with vivid, dark descriptions that practically ignite your senses—you can smell ash, taste blood, and hear swords clashing. This immersive writing brings the Norse mythology-inspired world to life, complete with gods, giants, magic, thralls, and dragons. While the magic system isn’t groundbreaking, it holds its own within a meticulously crafted world. The Shadow of the Gods is an experience of adjustment and awe, proving that Gwynne’s storytelling more than lives up to its reputation. Since I have read The Shadow of the Gods, I have read book two (with book three still on my TBR). The more I sit with the story the more I realize I love it. Check out my full review for a guest spot on After the Last Page.
Worst: The Curse of Penryth Hall by Jess Armstrong (4 stars)
Thinking back my read of The Curse of Penryth Hall is among the first I’ve done as an immersion read (both audio and physical). I realized then I am a girl who loves the atmosphere. Reading The Curse of Penryth Hall this way was perfection. So when I say that this is the worst it is by no means the worst book I’ve read. I loved Ruby as the main character. She was interesting and well-developed.
The prose adds a gothic feeling, allowing the setting to come alive. Out of my experience reading this tale, my biggest issue was that the book sometimes felt out of place, being cryptic and confusing. This could have been due to the mystery aspect, with the author wanting to keep you on your toes. Or (and I am leaning towards this) it was due to the writing. Where some aspects were well done other times (like this) just weren’t up to par. Check out my full review Penryth Mystery: Immersing in ‘The Curse of Penryth Hall’
February
Best: God of Malice by Rina Kent (5 stars)
I want to learn how to go back in time so I can read this for the first time again. That’s all I want to do! It’s all I need to do. I don’t even know where to start. I want to gush about it endlessly, yet I also want to say nothing because everyone needs to experience this book for themselves. IT’S JUST SO FLIPPING GOOD. I didn’t want it to end, but I couldn’t put it down.
The relationship dynamics, the rivalries, the way everyone interacts—oh my god, I was on the edge of my seat.
Killian Carson is EVERYTHING!
Glyn and Killian meet at the edge of a cliff, and it’s anything but friendly. Killian, a stunning man with a taste for cruelty, doesn’t hold back during their first encounter.
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: I absolutely love books about psychopaths and sociopaths falling in love. Something is fascinating about someone who doesn’t feel emotions traditionally finally falling for that one special person. Rina Kent masters this dynamic, earning her title as the queen of dark romance with her compelling anti-heroes.
The story is told from multiple perspectives, mainly Glyndon’s, but with plenty of insight into Killian’s mind as well.
Prepare for Killian and Glyn to rock your world. They’ve completely turned mine upside down. Their story is an absolute MASTERPIECE
Worst: Fathomfolk by Eliza Chan (DNF)
Fathomfolk was among my most anticipated reads of 2024. Fathomfolk promised an enticing tale of Asian mythology, political intrigue, and revolution set in the vivid, glittering city of Tiankawi—a metropolis blending sky-high skyscrapers and deep-sea magic. While the initial world-building of Tiankawi is immersive and vibrant, capturing the spirit of real-world cities like Hong Kong or Tokyo, the depth doesn’t extend to other settings, leaving the world feeling incomplete.
The story’s execution falters with sluggish pacing, underwhelming plot developments, and a lack of cohesion in its magical system. Questions about the logic of the underwater realm—like the need for food preservation or the use of weights—undermine the fantasy’s immersion. Moreover, cultural references, such as “kumiho” and “glashtyn,” feel misplaced and underexplored.
Marketed as adult fantasy, Fathomfolk reads more like YA, with juvenile tones and underdeveloped characters that fail to inspire emotional investment. Multiple POVs provide varied insights but suffer from inconsistent voices. The political and social themes, though intriguing, lack the depth needed to leave a lasting impact.
Despite its flaws, fans of The Drowning Empire or The Girl That Fell Beneath the Sea might appreciate the Asian mythology inspiration. With better marketing alignment and an understanding of its YA tone, Fathomfolk could find a more receptive audience. As for revisiting the series? Perhaps, but not anytime soon.
March
Best: The Sinner by Shantel Tessier (5 stars)
The Sinner is not just a book—it’s an experience. From the moment you step into its dark, twisted world, Shantel Tessier holds nothing back. The story grabs you by the throat with its intense, morally gray characters, tantalizing tension, and a deliciously sinful plot that keeps you turning pages deep into the night.
The centerpiece of the story is the enigmatic antihero, Sin—raw, dangerous, and utterly addictive. He’s the kind of character you shouldn’t root for, but somehow, you can’t resist. Tessier masterfully crafts a dynamic so intense it feels like it could ignite the pages. Every scene is dripping with dark desires, forbidden secrets, and power struggles that leave you breathless.
Go ahead—give in to temptation. Read The Sinner. You’ll thank me later.
Worst: Shadow and Bone by Leigh Bardugo (3 stars)
I went into Shadow and Bone expecting to fall in love with it. I decided to pick it up so that I could watch the show (I like to compare and contrast). Ultimately, I was left feeling underwhelmed. I can’t remember anything from the book (which is on brand for me, but this time I really can’t remember anything at all). At this point, I don’t know if I will be continuing the series. I do want to read Six of Crows so I may skip this and head into that one.
April
Best: Little Stranger by Leigh Rivers (5 stars)
This isn’t for the faint-hearted. This one is TABOO and you shouldn’t read it if you’re not into BDSM but Malachi oh Malachi. I recommend the audiobook it is *Chef’s Kiss*. Imagine wanting someone you know is off-limits, and they’re just as drawn to you. That’s the essence of Malachi Vize: intense possessiveness, a fierce “you’re mine” attitude, and a lethal “touch her and you’re done” vibe. The story is intoxicating, well-written, and has a luscious dark tone. Malachi is one of my favorite book boyfriends.
Worst: Do You Want Me? by Willow Winters (3 stars)
For me, prequels are supposed to engage you and set you up, peaking your interest to want to continue to the actual series. That just didn’t do it. Was it good? It wasn’t bad so there’s that. It just wasn’t enough to make me want to continue to the actual start of the series. Maybe this should have been within the first book as a backstory, or I should have read this after the first book. I do want to learn more about Marcus and the deal that he’s made so I guess that’s point 2. Other than that it was just meh
May
Best: Blood and Steel by Helen Scheuerer (5 stars)
If you haven’t read my review of Blood and Steel, check it out. Blood and Steel by Helen Scheuerer pulls you into a world where fate and determination collide. Thea, the fierce and quick-witted protagonist, knows the exact age she will die, and she’s fighting tooth and nail to accomplish her goals before her time runs out. While the premise may not be groundbreaking, the execution is where this book truly shines. From the vivid descriptions of windswept plains to battles against haunting monsters, you’ll feel like you’re right alongside Thea as she faces her challenges.
The story doesn’t spoon-feed you every detail, but instead, unravels its secrets gradually, especially as Thea’s backstory and the Guild’s purpose come into focus. For a richer understanding, the prequel Slaying the Shadow Prince is highly recommended.
Thea herself is a standout—strong, determined, and unapologetically flawed. Whether she’s navigating bullies like Seb Barlowe or standing up for her friends and chosen family, her resilience and loyalty make her incredibly endearing. While the romance is steamy, the book’s heart lies in its exploration of all kinds of relationships, reminding readers of the importance of connection even in the face of destiny.
Though it sometimes feels like YA due to its tone, the intensity of the romance and themes keep it firmly in the adult epic fantasy realm. Blood and Steel is a gripping tale of courage, friendship, and love that will leave you eager for the next installment.
Worst: The Witch’s Brew by L.B. Mammoth (2 stars)
This book has a cute concept, but the execution falls short. Grammatical errors and a lack of editing are glaring issues, with typos and awkward writing styles disrupting the flow. The story rushes through character development, summarizing conversations rather than showing them, which makes the romantic connection between the main characters feel unnatural. Additionally, the inconsistent tone—shifting between overly formal and casual—doesn’t suit the story’s lighter nature.
If you’re looking for a short, steamy read and can overlook poor grammar and structural issues, it might still be worth a try. However, many readers agree this book could benefit from significant revisions and a more polished approach.
Mid-way! You have to see what’s at the end of the 2024 Reading Recap
June
Best: God of Fury by Rina Kent (5 stars)
The Legacy of Gods series delivers yet another standout with God of Fury, earning a top spot alongside Killian (God of Malice). Nikolai is a character you can’t help but fall for—his mix of sweetness, possessiveness, and unhinged devotion strikes the perfect balance with Brandon’s grounded intensity. Their dynamic is magnetic, filled with raw passion, heartbreak, and moments that make your chest ache in the best way.
The storytelling is masterful, pulling you into every emotion as if you’re living it yourself. I found myself laughing, gasping, and sobbing—especially during the deeply emotional scenes. The pacing is flawless, with twists that kept me glued to every page. Whether reading physically or listening to the audiobook, God of Fury delivers a visceral, all-encompassing experience.
The depth of the characters, their growth, and the intricate relationships they share elevate this book to another level. It’s not just a romance; it’s a story about love, loss, loyalty, and fighting for what truly matters. The Legacy of Gods series continues to be an unforgettable journey, and God of Fury is one I will revisit time and again, each read uncovering new layers to love.
Worst: To Bleed a Crystal Bloom by Sarah A. Parker (DNF)
I am on team I need someone to tell me why they thought this book was good. To Bleed A Crystal Bloom was so hyped on the net and I feel like I shot myself in the foot (I don’t usually read hyped books). It had SO MUCH potential. But ultimately it left me with more questions than answers. In conjunction with all those questions, I was SO BORED. I understand that this book in theory is a foundational setup for the rest of the trilogy but NOTHING HAPPENS for the majority of the story. Laith is stuck in her routine and scared to venture outside of the safety line (and rightfully so) but when are we going to move past that 52% into the book and we’ve gotten no development, no experimentation, NOTHING!
July
Best: Castle of the Cursed by Romina Garber (5 stars)
Castle of the Cursed is a spellbinding journey into the heart of la Sombra, a haunted Spanish castle dripping with secrets and shadows. After a brutal attack takes her parents, Estela seeks refuge with her estranged aunt, only to find herself drawn into a web of mystery. Haunted by survivor’s guilt and a silver-eyed boy named Sebastián—who may or may not be real—Estela is thrust into an unraveling of family secrets, forbidden romance, and the chilling town of Oscuro.
Romina Garber crafts an unforgettable gothic tale, rich with atmosphere and suspense. The novel explores themes of grief, resilience, and self-discovery as Estela confronts the dark truths lurking in her family’s past. The “Raul’s Rule” interludes heighten the tension, while the poetic prose draws readers deeper into la Sombra’s eerie halls. The blend of romance, supernatural intrigue, and gothic allure makes this book irresistible, delivering a heart-pounding conclusion that will leave you desperate for more. You know a book is good when you stay up until 3 AM reading it. Check out my full review.
Worst: The Invisible Library by Genevieve Cogman (DNF)
You definitely should check out my full review of The Invisible Library to get the full effect. “The Invisible Library” by Genevieve Cogman captivates with its premise of immortal spy librarians navigating alternate realities. However, the execution falls short, leaving readers like me frustrated and ultimately unable to finish the book. The novel introduces intriguing elements like dragons and chaotic worlds but fails to integrate them cohesively into the plot. The writing, while abundant in description, lacks fluidity and emotional resonance. Its attempt to blend mature themes with a young adult style feels awkward, and the world-building lacks clarity and structure. Despite its potential, “The Invisible Library” struggles to engage, feeling more like a jumble of promising ideas than a polished narrative.
August
Best: Castle of Nevers and Nightmares by Lana Pecherczyk (5 stars)
My thoughts when finishing Castle of Nevers and Nightmares is what am I supposed to do until book two. I YEARNED for the second book in the series. Recommending it to everyone I came into contact with. I also reread it within a month because I couldn’t get the story off of my mind. It is just that good. The writing, the pacing, the plot! Plus, I will also STAN for a why-choose romance (because sometimes a girl needs more than one guy!) If you haven’t read my full review, do it. Maybe that (if this hasn’t already) will convince you to add it to your 2025 TBR.
Worst: Subspace by Stuart Stromin (3 stars)
There was nothing inherently wrong with Subspace. It was a pretty good read. But of everything that I read in the month of August, it was the weakest in the bunch. Reading this I realized that I am not a “short story” type of girl. Anthologies never feel fleshed out to me. I yearn for more and it is only so much development that can happen in ten to fifteen pages.
September
Best: Trials of Dusk and Dreams by Lana Pechercyzk (5 stars)
If Castle of Nevers and Nightmares (book one) was my favorite of August, Trials of Dusk and Dreams HAS TO BE the favorite of September. The wonderful writing extends into book two and I am SALIVATING for book three.
Worst: 5 Moons of Tiiana by P.T. Harry (3 stars)
The 5 Moons of Tiiana by P.T. Harry quickly draws readers in with its fast-paced action, puzzles, espionage, and secrets, although the flow is uneven at first. The book is highly engaging, but the world-building feels a bit lacking. The pacing is fast, keeping readers hooked, and the illustrations add to the immersive experience.
However, there are some confusing elements, particularly unexplained abbreviations like “PMs” and “ATs,” which detract from the story. Certain moments lack logical consistency, such as a scene involving missing silver, making it hard to invest in the narrative fully. Eventually, the story feels chaotic and overly campy, attempting to juggle too much at once without truly allowing readers to experience the moment.
Overall, the book is recommended for fans of sci-fi with epic space adventures and complex characters. While it has its shortcomings, The 5 Moons of Tiiana is a cinematic and immersive read, particularly for those drawn to action-packed, high-stakes drama. Check out my full review The 5 Moons of Tiiana: Epic Space Battles & Unforgettable Heroes
October
Best: Little Liar by Leigh Rivers (5 stars)
I LOVED Little Liar! Seeing the conclusion to Malachi and Olivia was bittersweet (unhinged, but bittersweet). Leigh masterfully delivers twists, betrayal, suspense, and spice, crafting a perfect ending to Malachi and Olivia’s love story. I am hoping that Leigh does a series with the Reznikov brothers and Abigail because I need to know their story.
Worst: Bitterblue by Sam Martin (DNF)
Bitterblue wasn’t for me. It was hard to follow along with all of the head-hopping. Mid-sentence you would then be switched to another perspective and after 10 minutes of that, I had given up. I didn’t even get past chapter two. Could this have been one where it got better the more I read? Sure, but life’s too short to be continuously confused while reading.
November
Best: Fae Dynasty duology by Victoria McCombs (5 stars)
I had so much fun with this duology (you should check out my full review). It has been a long time since I have read a book that plays into the trickster nature of the Fae. Current books tend to focus on the beauty of them and the magic they display. The world-building throughout the books is rich and captivating. With Mortal Queens, McCombs creates a world that’s as flawed as its characters, full of political games, betrayal, and shifting power. The duology doesn’t shy away from the messiness of life, and its raw, unpolished quality makes it all the more compelling. If you’re looking for a fantasy series with rich world-building, complex characters, and high-stakes drama, Mortal Queens and Lethal Kings is a must-read.
Worst: Emperor of Rage by Jagger Cole (DNF)
I dove into Emperor of Rage by Jagger Cole with high hopes—especially since it’s my first read from a top author in a mafia romance. The beginning had me hooked instantly; within the first chapter, I knew I was in for a wild ride. But as I read further, my excitement faded. The pacing felt inconsistent, with some parts rushing by while others dragged on, making the romance feel lackluster and the story disjointed. Mal and Freya, the main characters, share a traumatic past, but rather than immersing us in their history through flashbacks or deeper emotional moments, much of it is just explained, which left me struggling to connect.
On top of that, the plot felt repetitive, with familiar mafia romance tropes like “I own you” and “do what I say” dominating but without much innovation. By the time I reached 150 pages, I decided it wasn’t for me. Still, I can see why Jagger Cole has a loyal following, and I’m open to trying his other books in the future. If you’re a mafia romance fan, give Emperor of Rage a go—you might find it resonates with you in ways it didn’t for me. I have a full review if you want to know more.
December
Best: My Feral Romance by Tessonja Odette (4 stars)
My Feral Romance by Tessonja Odette is a cozy, low-stakes fantasy romance that delivers heart, humor, and plenty of spark. Daphne and Monty, introduced as side characters in A Rivalry of Hearts, shine as the protagonists in this enchanting tale of flirty lessons, rekindled passion, and steamy romance. Odette’s prose feels like stepping into a dream—vivid, comforting, and laced with just the right touch of magic. Her world-building is immersive yet intimate, creating a backdrop that enhances the characters’ emotions without overshadowing them. From playful banter to heartfelt confessions, the chemistry between Daphne and Monty is irresistible, making their friends-to-lovers journey a delight for fans of Bridgerton-esque matchmaking and cozy fantasy worlds.
While the book sparkles with charm, some moments, like Araminta’s role, feel underdeveloped, leaving her story disconnected from the larger narrative. However, the overall experience is an enchanting escape filled with humor, passion, and magic. Perfect for readers seeking a cozy, whimsical romance, My Feral Romance is a story worth getting lost in. My full review is a MUST READ A Love as Wild as the Woods: My Feral Romance Review.
Worst: Lights Among the Interstate by Adam Fike (3 stars)
With an interesting premise, Lights Along The Interstate promises interwoven allegories to measure humankind’s success. At first glance, the stories feel disjointed, almost as if each chapter is a short story. As it continues, the stories meld. Creating a captivating, streamlined story that, beyond everything else, is super well written. It’s interesting, gripping you increasingly as you turn the pages and immerse yourself further, carrying you along the entertaining journey. What prohibits me from giving it a four or even a 5-star rating is that I wish it were longer. Exploring the characters more and deepening my connection. Overall, it’s a story you should read and experience for yourself.
