Hit & Run Had Everything I Wanted…Except the Romance
We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.
A bounty hunter and a serial killer walk into a dark romantic comedy. What could possibly go wrong?
Apparently, quite a bit.
In Hit and Run, what starts as an unconventional encounter between two people who couldn’t be more different sets the stage for what should be one hell of a dark romantic comedy.
Parker Presley is a Bounty Hunter working for a super-secret government agency called The Blood Sport Agency that caters to Manhattan’s wealthy elite. Holden Hammer, her infuriatingly attractive new neighbor, just so happens to be a serial killer.
On paper, it has all the ingredients for a deliciously twisted enemies-to-lovers romance. And as someone who enjoys dark humor, morally questionable characters, and an unconventional love story, I was curious to see how it would all come together.
Unfortunately, my reading experience took a rather unexpected turn.

Title: Hit & Run (A Blood Sport Agency, 1)
Author: Kinsley Kincaid
Publisher: Independently Published
Format: eBook (Kindle+)
Genre: Dark Romance, Dark Rom-Com, Contemporary
Release Date: June 16, 2026
Pages: 303
Star Rating: DNF at page 200
Spice Rating: 0 chili peppers (at the point of DNF)
The Good: Let’s Give Credit Where It’s Due
I think my problem with Hit & Run is that I was genuinely enjoying myself. Until I wasn’t.
So, why don’t we get the good out of the way before we get into the bad, shall we?
My favorite thing about Hit & Run was the storytelling style. There’s something about the conversational nature of the prose that makes the story feel surprisingly intimate. Throughout the story, the fourth wall is broken, with the main characters speaking directly to you (and the other characters wondering who she is talking to) rather than simply narrating the events unfolding around her.
I liked that. It gave the story a certain personality and made those opening chapters easy to settle into.
The humor was another aspect I initially enjoyed, particularly when it came to the supporting characters. Their interactions felt playful and natural. There were moments when the comedy landed exactly as I imagine the author intended.
And then there were the characters themselves.
When Hit & Run started, I was intrigued by the contrast between the two leads. On one side, we have a chaotic, absolutely impulsive bounty hunter who seems to find amusement in just about everything. (Especially baby animals.) On the other, we have a tightly wound serial killer whose need for order and control makes him an interesting counterpart to her personality. It’s an unusual combination, and I was curious to see what the author would do with it.
Holden: A Hot, Murderous Monk, Anyone?
I need to take a moment to talk about Holden, because I actually found him fascinating.
Have you ever watched Monk? Because the best way I can describe this man is a hot, murderous version of Adrian Monk. And I don’t know about you, but that combo immediately had my attention.
His obsessive need for order, his rigid routines, and the way his mind operates made him a great character to read. (Although he isn’t making it into the top book boyfriends.) There’s something fascinating about a character who needs everything to exist in a certain structure, especially when that structure begins to unravel.
And I wanted to understand him. Not necessarily to excuse his behavior, because please let’s not forget we are talking about a serial killer here, but to understand what made him tick.
Even as his behavior became increasingly erratic, I found myself curious about what was happening inside that head of his and where the psychological unraveling might lead.
He was, without question, the character who held my attention the most throughout Hit & Run. (Oh! And Mr. Carlisle 😂)
This Is Where It Went Off the Rails
But I’m afraid that’s where my praise ends. Because what I found fascinating about one character, I found absolutely insufferable in the other.
So, it probably goes without saying that if I found Holden fascinating, the character I found absolutely insufferable could only be his romantic counterpart.
And let me make this point: I didn’t dislike her from the beginning.
In fact, I initially found her chaotic, whimsical personality somewhat endearing. Her obsession with adorable animals and her impulsiveness were amusing enough in those opening chapters. But as the story progressed, those same qualities became increasingly frustrating.
But rather than discovering new layers to her personality, I felt as though I was watching her characterization deteriorate. The traits that initially made her quirky and entertaining became so exaggerated that she began to feel like a child with money and a badge rather than a believable person.
It wasn’t that I wanted her to become less whimsical or suddenly transform into someone serious. Not at all. I wanted her behavior to make sense within the situations she found herself in.

She’s a bounty hunter who supposedly thrives on the thrill of the chase, yet she can’t seem to give her own team five minutes of attention while they’re briefing her about her next target. At some point, what was meant to be charming stopped being funny and started undermining my ability to believe in her as a character.
But my frustration with her characterization was only part of the problem.
Because where was the romantic tension?
We’re talking about a dark enemies-to-lovers romantic comedy. And while I don’t expect two characters to fall into each other’s arms within the first few chapters, I do expect the story to give me a reason to even want them together.
Instead, I was left feeling as though I was watching two characters living entirely separate lives, with their individual storylines drifting further apart rather than drawing them closer together.
And yes, I completely understand that Hit & Run could be categorized as a slow burn and the first book in a duet🙄. But a slow burn still needs to fucking burn. There should be something beneath the hostility that makes you anticipate what might happen when these two finally collide.
For me, that something was missing.
At the end of the day, this is still a romance. And no matter how dark, chaotic, or unconventional the story becomes, the developing relationship needs to remain one of its emotional anchors. If it isn’t, then what was the point of it all?
A brief moment for the Romance of hit & run…
And while we’re on the subject of romance, can we talk about the enemies-to-lovers aspect for a moment?
Because here’s the thing: just because two characters exist on opposite sides of the law doesn’t inherently make them enemies.
She is a bounty hunter working for a government agency. He is a serial killer. Naturally, their professions put them at odds with one another, but that alone doesn’t establish the kind of personal conflict I’d expect from an enemies-to-lovers romance.
There needs to be something more. A rivalry, opposing motivations, a genuine threat to one another’s goals. Something that makes me understand not only why these two characters are against each other, but why their eventual attraction would complicate that opposition.
And for much of Hit & Run, I didn’t feel conflict existed between them at all.
It isn’t until roughly 60% of the book that she actively begins hunting him. And while that finally establishes a tangible reason for them to be adversaries, by that point, I was already struggling to invest in their relationship.
The potential was there. A bounty hunter pursuing a serial killer could have made for a deliciously twisted game of cat and mouse, especially with their contrasting personalities.
But instead of watching their rivalry develop alongside an increasingly complicated attraction, I felt as though I was waiting for the enemies-to-lovers story to actually begin.
By that point, I no longer cared. And if you don’t care what happens next, what’s the point of turning another page?

Your Turn, Dear Reader: Let’s Talk Books
Have you read Hit & Run? I’d love to know your thoughts, especially if you had a completely different experience than I did.
If you’re curious enough to give it a chance, consider supporting an independent bookstore and picking up your own copy of Hit & Run. Who knows? You might find everything in this story that I was missing.
And if you love talking about books, debating characters, and sharing your unfiltered opinions, we’ve started a book club over on Fable. Come join us in the Wildcard Reading Club! Whether you loved a book, hated it, or couldn’t bring yourself to finish it, there’s always room for another perspective at the table.
Read These Next:
The Invisible Hour: A Journey into Alice Hoffman’s Literary Magic
‘Butcher and Blackbird’: Darkly Irresistible Book You Need to Read
Extreme Dark Romance Books That Cross the Line







