The Bookshop Below: Magical Bookshops, Forbidden Secrets, and Ink Magic

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.

What if a bookshop could change your life? What if it wasn’t just a place to find your next favorite story, but a place where stories could change the course of your destiny?

Beneath the streets of London, a secret network of magical bookshops has existed for centuries, offering powerful bargains, dangerous enchantments, and the kind of magic that lingers long after you’ve closed the book. But these extraordinary bookshops are slowly disappearing, and the secrets behind their decline may be more dangerous than anyone can realize.

In The Bookshop Below by Georgia Summers, readers are invited into a world where books hold extraordinary power, ink becomes a deadly tool, and the woman at the center of the mystery has a story of her own she wants to rewrite. Cassandra Fairfax was once a respected bookseller until her mentor cast her out and the magical bookshop she called home began to close its doors.

Now surviving through stolen books and questionable dealings, Cassandra finds herself drawn back into the very world she thought she lost the day she left.

But inheriting a legacy is never quite so simple when rival booksellers are lurking in the shadows, a murderer remains at large, and a dark-eyed, regrettably handsome bookseller keeps darkening your doorstep.

The Bookshop Below is a standalone that promises a fantasy adventure for readers who love the idea that there is always something extraordinary waiting between the covers of the book. But is it worth adding to your TBR?

Title: The Bookshop Below

Author: Georgia Summers

Publisher: Redhook

Format: eARC

Genre: Books about Books, Romance, Fantasy, Urban Fantasy, Magic

Release Date: November 18, 2025

Pages: 374

Star Rating: 3.5

Spice Rating: one scene fade to black

High Hopes for The Bookshop Below

Having read Georgia Summers’ debut novel The City of Stardust (read my review) and thoroughly enjoyed it, I was excited to pick up The Bookshop Below. Books about books are one of my favorite subgenres, and with its secret network of magical bookshops, a splash of tarot symbolism, and deadly ink magic, this novel has all the ingredients to capture my imagination.

Needless to say, I went into this one with pretty high hopes.

One of the best things about The Bookshop Below is the protagonist, Cassandra. She’s flawed, a thief, and a self-proclaimed master liar, but there’s something undeniably compelling about her. Her connection to the bookshop runs so deep that, as a child, it surprised her to discover that when she cut herself, she bled blood instead of ink. It’s a small detail, but it ultimately speaks volumes about how thoroughly the bookshop has shaped who she is and how inseparable she is from the world she’s grown up in.

But what makes Cassandra such an interesting protagonist isn’t simply her questionable morals or her talent for deception. It’s the complicated relationship with the world that shaped her, and what happens when the one place she considered home becomes the center of a mystery she can’t ignore.

When the Magical Worldbuilding Falls Short

And here’s the thing: while characters like Cassandra keep the story going, I wish things like the worldbuilding and pacing kept me invested.

There is a complete lack of worldbuilding in The Bookshop Below. Now, granted, the story is set in contemporary London built around magical realism, so perhaps the assumption is that readers already know the setting. But knowing London and understanding a world where magical bookshops have existed for millennia are two very different things.

I wanted more.

More about how these bookshops operate, more about the magic that makes them extraordinary, and more about how this hidden network exists alongside the world we know. Instead, I often felt as though the pieces were placed in front of me in rough shapes without enough development to make the world feel as immersive as its premise promised.

And that lack of immersion was carried through to the pacing. The Bookshop Below is slow, almost unnecessarily so. There are entire sections that drag, leaving me wondering when something would happen to propel the story forward.

Now, a slower pace isn’t inherently a bad thing, especially in fantasy, where atmosphere and worldbuilding can make the journey just as rewarding as reaching the destination. But when the world itself isn’t developed enough to hold your attention, those slower stretches become much more noticeable. Instead of drawing me deeper into Cassandra’s story, it feels like you’re on the outside waiting for the plot to find its footing.

Ink Magic, Magical Readers, and a System That Needs More Clarity

And if the lack of worldbuilding and the pacing are bad, it is compounded by the lack of explanation when it comes to the magic system.

The bookshops are fuelled by a magical river, and I find the dissonance of what fuels the magic being the very thing that ordinarily would destroy the books utterly interesting. Ink is both a source of power and, in a world built around books, something that could threaten the very things these shops exist to protect. There’s so much potential in that contradiction, but I digress.

Those who drink the ink and “read” are called readers, but I struggled to understand what reading actually entails. From what I’ve gathered, readers draw magic from the river to manipulate or rework moments, but the mechanics of how this works remain unclear. There are limits, such as the possibility of becoming ink-sick, but I never got a strong sense of where those boundaries lie or what readers can and cannot do. Without a clearer understanding of the rules, it becomes difficult to grasp the full scope of the magic or what makes its use consequential.

Then there’s the ink magic itself, which often feels like an entirely separate system rather than an extension of the same one. The explanations surrounding both are muddled and sparse, and I struggled to understand how they intersect. If reading requires ink, yet ink magic operates in ways that feel distinctly different, I wanted a clearer explanation of what separates the two and how they function within the same world. Instead, the magic left me with more questions than answers, and not necessarily the intriguing kind that makes you eager to turn the next page.

And don’t even get me started on the paradox books…but again, I digress.

the bookshop below a book about books taken by the diary of a reader

An Ending That Makes The Journey Worthwhile

Despite the issues I had with The Bookshop Below (including a few I haven’t even touched here), I have to give credit where credit is due: that ending was SO GOOD. There are revelations that had me stopping to think, Wait, WHAT?! The kind of moments that make you rethink what you’ve read and suddenly see things a little differently.

What I particularly loved, though, was the open-ended conclusion. It leaves you wondering where the characters go from here and what might await them beyond the final page, while still giving the story a beautiful sense of completion.

It strikes that delicate balance between leaving the door open for possibility and allowing the story you’ve just read to feel complete. And honestly, after everything I wished had been developed more throughout The Bookshop Below, the ending reminded me why I had such high hopes for it in the first place.

Stay in the Reading Loop

Discover your next favorite read, get bookish recommendations, and receive a little literary magic straight to your inbox. Join Notes from a Reader Who Feels Everything

Shop Indie

Every independent bookstore has a story of its own. Find your next treasured read and show love to the bookshops that keep our literary world thriving.

SHOP BOOKSHOP.ORG

SHOP AMAZON.COM

SHOP LIBRO.FM

Read With Us + get 2 free books

You definitely need more reads added to your TBR.

Join the Wildcard Reading Club of Fable for our monthly reads, unhinged reactions, and a community of mood readers who refuse to stay in one genre.

And while I’m making your TBR WORSE…

Start your Everand trial and get 2 free book credits.

Use code: DEARDIARY

JOIN THE WILDCARD READING CLUB

GET 2 FREE BOOKS ON EVERAND